![]() |
||||
71 Killed in Japan Train DerailmentBy MARI YAMAGUCHI AMAGASAKI, Japan (AP) - 0425japan-train The death toll jumped to 71 Tuesday as crews pulled more victims from the wreckage of Japan's deadliest rail crash in decades. Investigators focused on whether excessive speed or the driver's inexperience caused the train to derail and slam into a building. The seven-car commuter train carrying 580 passengers left the rails Monday morning near Amagasaki, a suburb of Osaka about 250 miles west of Tokyo. It hit an automobile and then a nine-story apartment complex. More than 440 people were injured. Rescuers working under floodlights pulled out a conscious but seriously injured 46-year-old woman then reached a 19-year-old man passenger, also in serious condition. But most of the work was grim as crews pulled 14 more bodies from the twisted rail carriages, pushing the death toll from 57 to 71. Two of the five derailed cars were shoved inside and flattened against the wall of the building's first-floor parking garage. Distraught relatives rushed to hospitals looking for loved ones who might have been injured or killed in the 5:18 a.m. crash. They struggled to comprehend their loss. "I only saw him the night before," said Hiroko Kuki, whose son died in the crash. "I wish he were alive somewhere... I wish it were only a nightmare." Takamichi Hayashi said his elder brother, 19-year-old Hiroki, might be among those still in the wreck. He said Hiroki had called their mother twice on a mobile phone from inside one of the train cars hours after the crash but remained unaccounted for. "He told my mother: 'I'm in pain. I'm not going to make it,'" Hayashi said. Officials said no cause had been ruled out but added that investigators suspected speed and the driver's less than a year on the job. The driver - identified as Ryujiro Takami, 23 - was unaccounted for. He got his train operator's license last May. A month later, he overshot a station and was issued a warning, railway officials and police said. Passengers said he also stopped too far past a station platform Monday just before the crash. Tsunemi Murakami, safety director for train operator West Japan Railway Co., said it had not been determined how fast the train was traveling. A surviving crew member told police he "felt the train was going faster than usual," public broadcaster NHK said. That echoed comments from passengers who speculated the driver might have been speeding to make up for time lost when he overshot the previous station by 25 feet and had to back up. The train was nearly two minutes behind schedule, media reports said. The crash occurred on a curve with a speed limit of 43 mph . Murakami estimated the train would have had to be traveling at 82 mph to have jumped the track purely because of excessive speed. Some stretches of track in Japan have safety systems designed to stop trains at any sign of trouble without requiring drivers to take emergency action. But transport ministry officials said the automatic braking system along the stretch of track where the train crashed is among the oldest in Japan and can't halt trains traveling at high speeds. Outside experts predicted investigators would find a combination of factors to blame. "There are very few train accidents in Japan in which a train has flipped just because it was going too fast. There might have been several conditions at work - speed, winds, poor train maintenance or aging rails," Kazuhiko Nagase, a train expert who is a professor at the Kanazawa Institute of Technology, told NHK. "For the train to flip, it had to be traveling at an extremely high speed," Nagase said. Murakami said investigators also found evidence of rocks on the tracks, but hadn't determined whether that contributed to the crash. Transport Minister Kazuo Kitagawa told reporters he would order all of Japan's railway operators to conduct safety inspections in the coming days. "It's tragic," Kitagawa said at the scene. "We have to investigate why this horrible accident happened." Deadly train accidents are rare in Japan, which is home to one of the world's most complex, efficient and heavily traveled rail networks. Monday's crash was the worst since 161 people died in a three-train crash in 1963 at Tsurumi, outside Tokyo. --
DAILY YOMIURU (27.04.2004) Speed cited in fatal crash The Yomiuri Shimbun The seven-car train that derailed Monday morning on the JR Fukuchiyama Line in Amagasaki, Hyogo Prefecture, killing at least 76 people and injuring hundreds, approached a curve at more than 100 kph before jumping the tracks, investigators said Tuesday. According to police and fire department authorities, nearly 30 people were trapped in the first and second cars, and it was not known whether they were alive. The lead car of the train became airborne due to its high speed before crashing into the apartment building, police said Tuesday. They added that the first car may have bounced after derailing and hit an electricity pole along the line. Analyzing equipment collected from the fifth car that recorded the train's speed and other data, they found the brakes were applied as it approached the curve. Police received operational records and employee schedules from eight West Japan Railway Co. facilities in connection with Monday's fatal accident. As of 10 p.m. Tuesday, 76 people were confirmed killed and 456 hurt, the police and other sources said. The police confiscated a pocketbook and other belongings of the train's 23-year-old driver, Ryujiro Takami, from his office. The Construction and Transport Ministry's Aircraft and Railway Accidents Investigation Commission said the accident was a result of multiple causes, including the train's speeding, adding it would take days to identify the primary cause of the accident. A commission member said, "The accident seems different from those of any other rollover accidents caused by speeding." The police will soon start investigating JR West on suspicion of professional negligence resulting in death and injury. JR West President Takeshi Kakiuchi is likely to resign from his post to take responsibility for the accident as there is a strong possibility that the accident resulted mainly from the firm's negligence. Chairman Shojiro Nanya, 63, also is likely to resign. According to the police, the concrete electricity pole near the point on the track where the train's seventh car stopped was severely damaged. The pole is located about three meters from the track. Crossties before the pole also were found to have been damaged. Thus the police concluded that the train derailed at this point, and the first car of the train hit the pole shortly after it went off the tracks. Wheel marks were found for several meters alongside the track, starting from a point near the pole, but they became shallower the closer they came to the apartment building. As white powder, believed to have come from crushed stones, was found on the track, JR West suspects someone placed stones on the railway track, causing the accident. White powder was found on an outer track of the bend, about 11 meters before the spot where the train derailed. Crushed stones were also found on some crossties. From the amount of residue, JR West suspects that fist-sized stones had been placed on the track, as larger stones are knocked away by a mechanism on the lead car to remove obstacles from the tracks. According to JR West, drivers and other crew members of five trains that passed the spot before the accident, including a rapid train that passed there four minutes earlier, saw no stones. The police are skeptical that stones caused the accident, claiming it is unrealistic to believe that someone placed stones on the tracks within the four-minute interval between trains during rush hour, and no eyewitnesses have come forward. === Conductor admits false report The train's 42-year-old conductor, Masatoshi Matsushita, said Monday night after the accident that he had made an arrangement with the driver to say that the train had overshot the stop line at Itami Station by eight meters, although it had actually overshot by 40 meters , before he reported the irregularity to JR West
Dozens die as train hits housing block 04/26/2005
NEWSDAY.COM By MARI YAMAGUCHI AMAGASAKI, Japan -- Rescuers pulled two survivors -- but also more bodies -- from the gnarled wreckage of Japan's worst train crash in decades Tuesday, and investigators raided the rail operator's offices for clues about why the train skidded off the tracks, killing at least 78 people. At least 456 people were injured.
--The Asahi Shimbun, April 26(IHT/Asahi: April 27,2005) 04/27/2005
Train crash kills 71, injures 441 Compiled from Kyodo, staff reports The accident occurred at around 9:20 a.m. near a railway crossing between Amagasaki and Tsukaguchi stations on West Japan Railway Co.'s Fukuchiyama Line. The first and second cars of the train crashed into the ground floor of the nine-story apartment building about 6 meters from the curved tracks and were destroyed. As of Monday evening, rescuers were trying to free at least four people still alive in the wreckage. Rescue work continued through the night. Hundreds of injured people were taken to nearby hospitals, police said. Government and JR West officials said they were trying to determine the cause of the accident. Several passengers said they thought the train was going too fast. The number of deaths surpassed the 42 people who died in a 1991 head-on train collision in Shiga Prefecture. JR West said it found grinding marks on the tracks often left behind when a train runs over objects such as stones, but added they had not confirmed any causal relationship between the marks and the accident. The 23-year-old driver, who had been on the job for 11 months, overshot a station stop in June last year by 100 meters , JR West said. He was still missing in the wreckage as of Monday evening. The 42-year-old conductor on the train was interviewed by police, JR West officials said. JR West President Takeshi Kakiuchi apologized for the accident. "As a railway operator, I am filled with a very sorry feeling," he said at a news conference in Osaka. At a separate news conference in the evening, the railway operator said the accident led to the cancellation of 280 train runs, affecting 120,000 passengers. In response to requests by the Hyogo Prefectural Government, a Ground Self-Defense Force unit in the prefecture sent personnel to help with rescue operations, while nearby municipalities such as Osaka and Kobe sent firefighters to provide emergency aid. The train, with about 580 people on board, was heading from Takarazuka Station in Hyogo Prefecture to Doshishamae Station in Kyoto Prefecture. The speed limit at the accident site was 70 kph, but it is not known how fast the train was going when the accident occurred, JR West officials said. The automatic transfer switch used in the area is the oldest model available and does not have the capability to trigger automatic braking when trains go by too quickly, the Land, Infrastructure and Transport Ministry said. At Itami Station, the train's last stop before crashing, the driver overran the stop mark by about 8 meters and had to back up before the passengers could be let off, a JR West official said. The train then left the station about 90 seconds behind schedule and passed Tsukaguchi Station about one minute late, he said. The conductor was reporting to the command room about the overrun at Itami Station by radio and mobile phone when the accident occurred, JR West said. "We just had a derailment accident," the conductor said through the phone, the company said. Many of the injured said the train seemed to be traveling faster than usual after leaving Itami Station, as if the driver was hurrying to make up for the delay. JR West sources suggested the train may have exceeding the speed limit and likely failed to negotiate the curve. Based on calculations, a train going by the accident site would derail if it were moving at 133 kph or more, JR West officials said. The train was designed to move at a maximum speed of 120 kph, they said
DAILY YOIMURI 56 die as train slams into building The Yomiuri Shimbun A seven-car train on the JR Fukuchiyama Line derailed and crashed into an apartment building Monday morning in Amagasaki, Hyogo Prefecture, killing 56 passengers and injuring 440, as of Monday night, police and other sources said. The front four cars on the train, which was carrying about 600 passengers, ran off the tracks before the front two cars slammed into a nine-story apartment building east of the tracks after ripping through a parking lot on the north side of the building. The front cars were crushed against the building, leaving many passengers trapped for hours. In the evening, rescue workers confirmed four passengers alive inside the first car, which slammed into the first floor of the building. The train's 23-year-old driver, Ryujiro Takami, was believed to have been trapped in the first car, according to the police. The accident occurred at about 9:20 a.m. when the train was en route to Doshishamae Station in Kyoto Prefecture from Takarazuka Station in Hyogo Prefecture. The train was traveling around a bend to the right at the time of the accident. West Japan Railway Co. said the speed limit at the turn was 70 kph. According to JR West and Railway Technical Research Institute, a train would need to be traveling faster than 133 kph to derail at the spot. JR West, however, said the train that crashed was designed to have a top speed of only 120 kph. The railway firm said it was unsure what speed the train was traveling at the time of the accident. JR West found no evidence that another vehicle caused the derailment. Hyogo prefectural police questioned the train's 42-year-old conductor. According to the police, the train overshot the stop line at Itami Station by eight meters and was forced to reverse, putting the train about 90 seconds behind schedule. The police quoted the conductor as saying, "It looked like the train was running a little faster than usual, so I wondered if the operator attempted to make up for the delay." Passengers also said the train seemed to be traveling faster than usual after overshooting the station. An eyewitness said the train's front car leaned and derailed after its brakes made squealing noises, adding that it only took about 10 seconds for the train to crash into the apartment building after it derailed. The driver of the train had only 11 months experience. According to JR West, he overshot Shimokoma Station in Kyoto Prefecture on the JR Gakkentoshi Line by about 100 meters in June. According to the railway firm, white powder that looked like crushed stone was found on the railway track near the accident site. JR West said it also would investigate whether there had been any obstruction on the tracks. The Construction and Transport Ministry's Aircraft and Railway Accident Investigation Commission sent three investigators to the site. The Hyogo prefectural government set up a task force to deal with the accident. Responding to the prefectural government's request, the Ground Self-Defense Force dispatched 50 members from the third division in Itami, Hyogo Prefecture, to help with rescue efforts. The central government also established a liaison office at the Prime Minister's Office to deal with rescue operations. The crash was the worst train accident since a head-on collision of JR West and Shigaraki Kogen Railway Co. trains on the Shigaraki Kogen line in May 1991 that killed 42 passengers. JR West President Takeshi Kakiuchi said during a press conference at its headquarters in Kita Ward, Osaka, "As a train operator, we feel very sorry for the victims."
DAILY YOMIURU 27_04_2005 Safety gear faulted in crash The Yomiuri Shimbun While the real cause of Monday's catastrophic train accident in Amagasaki, Hyogo Prefecture, that killed more than 70 passengers and injured hundreds remains under investigation, experts are blaming lax safety measures. According to the experts, West Japan Railway Co. has not replaced safety devices with more advanced versions to prevent serious accidents on such lines as the JR Fukuchiyama Line. Most train lines have been equipped with an automatic train stop, or ATS, system that automatically applies emergency brakes to stop a train when it passes a red light. The most advanced system is the automatic train stop pattern, or ATS-P system, which calculates the maximum speed at which a train can travel safely based on information transmitted from a device installed between rails. However, the Fukuchiyama Line's ATS system was the oldest version, ATS-SW, which originally was developed by defunct Japanese National Railways. JR West improved the system and added SW to the name. This system only automatically stops a train when an operator misses a red light or a train is about to crash into a buffer stop. The ATS-SW is not designed to prevent speeding on curves. According to JR West, the company planned to introduce ATS-P on the Fukuchiyama Line from June. The automatic train control system, or ATC, has been introduced on some trains in the Tokyo metropolitan area. ATC is more sophisticated and was originally developed for Shinkansen bullet trains. ATC automatically controls the speed of a train so that it does not exceed speed limits. However, an ATC requires a system that transmits electronic signals through rails and only recently was implemented on the JR Yamanote Line and Keihintohoku Line. A senior official of the Construction and Transport Ministry's Railway Bureau said, "It's a slow process, replacing safety devices on existing lines." In the latest fatal train accident, a train smashed into an apartment building, bending the cars beyond recognition. It is highly likely that the impact was more severe than anyone could have imagined possible in a train accident. The cars were made of stainless steel and were part of the 207 series, which have been manufactured since 1991, and about 480 have been built as of fiscal 2003. The model did not require paint, which made the cars lighter and therefore faster, and less susceptible to rusting. However, stainless steel is not as strong as regular steel, and therefore the train suffered an immense amount of damage. "One of possible reasons for the serious extent of the damage in the latest accident is that the material of the ultralight car was so susceptible to damage from impact," said Nobuyuki Sato, a lecturer at Asia University's economic department who specializes in transport policies. Train car manufacturers have objected to such reasoning, saying the car was designed to withstand impact, and the materials used did not weaken the design. However, train car designs are based on the assumption that any crashes will involve a front or rear collision. Impact to the side of a car was unforeseen. The senior official of the bureau said, "There are limitations on building strong cars, and measures should be implemented to stop a train safely if it derails." In the latest accident, the train ran off the rails and crashed into an apartment building. It is possible that the accident would not have been as serious if the train had been equipped with so-called derailment guards--a second set of rails installed between the main set. In the wake of a derailment on the Hibiya subway line in March 2000, the ministry instructed railway companies to install derailment guards on turns that were less than 200 meters in radius. JR West installed the guards at turns that were less than 250 meters in radius. The turn involved in the latest accident, however, was 300 meters in radius. However, rocks or other objects that become stuck in the guards could derail a train. Railway companies are reluctant to install the measures due to their cost and frequent maintenance requirements, according to observers.
KYODO NEWS Train crash death toll rises to 73, over 450 injured OSAKA , April 26, Kyodo - (EDS: CLARIFYING 1ST, 2ND AND 8TH GRAFS) The death toll in Monday's commuter train derailment and crash in Amagasaki, western Japan, rose to 73 Tuesday, with at least 456 people injured, some seriously, police said. After rescuing several survivors from the wreckage earlier in the day, the police and firefighters tried to confirm the safety of 14 or 15 people trapped in the mangled cars by using equipment to detect heartbeats with electromagnetic waves, but none of them is believed to be alive. Given statements from the train conductor and passengers that the train was traveling faster than usual at the time it derailed, the police launched an investigation of train operator West Japan Railway Co. (JR West) on Tuesday on suspicion of professional negligence resulting in death and injury. Investigators raided the railway operator's offices to obtain materials related to the train crash in Amagasaki, Hyogo Prefecture, just west of Osaka. Underlining the statements from the train conductor and passengers, the police have found the rapid-service train advanced to a curve at the crash site at a speed of more than 100 kilometers per hour, although the curved section has a speed limit of 70 kph, investigative sources said. The train theoretically would derail if its speed exceeded 130 kph but it was designed to have a top speed of 120 kph, according to JR West. A uniformed man believed to be the train driver, Ryujiro Takami, 23, has been found to still be in the driver's seat, but it has not been confirmed if he is dead or alive, the police said. He has not responded to rescue workers' calls, they said. The first two cars of the seven-vehicle train plowed into the first floor parking area of a nine-story apartment building, located about 6 meters from the tracks. The firefighters completed removal of the third to seventh cars Tuesday. It is the worst railway accident in Japan since the Japan Railway group was formed from the privatization of the state-run Japanese National Railways in 1987. The accident occurred Monday morning on a curve near a railway crossing on JR West's Fukuchiyama Line, when the train was heading from Tsukaguchi Station to Amagasaki Station. JR West said Monday the train had an overrun of about 8 meters at Itami Station, but at a press conference Tuesday it revised the overrun distance to about 40 meters . Many passengers said the train, which left the previous stop at Itami Station 90 seconds behind schedule, appeared to be traveling faster than usual. The train's conductor, Masatoshi Matsushita, 42, told JR West officials that the driver asked him after the incident at Itami Station to report a smaller overrun distance and so he conveyed to the command center three minutes later and said the train had an overrun of 8 meters , according to JR West. After backing up to let passengers on and off at Itami Station, the driver apparently tried to make up for the delay by increasing speed and the train passed Tsukaguchi Station, the second station from Itami, about one minute behind schedule. Just before the accident, JR West's command center contacted the driver twice but the driver did not respond, according to the railway company. According to JR West, Takami, who has been driving trains for 11 months, previously worked as a conductor and had a record of two reprimands in that post -- one for failing to pull an emergency lever when a train overran a platform in May 2002 and another over a passenger's report that he looked ''absent-minded'' while on duty in August 2003. He also received a reprimand as a driver for a platform overrun of about 100 meters in June last year.
The Asahi Shimbun 04/27/2005
The Japan Times: April 27, 2005 Train took curve at over 100 kph The speed limit at the accident site was 70 kph, according to West Japan Railway Co., the operator of the JR Fukuchiyama Line train. The company has said derailment can occur at 130 kph. The Hyogo Prefectural Police determined the speed by analyzing records in a device recovered from the wrecked train to automatically record train speed, officials said. The Hyogo police believe the cause of the accident may have been excessive speed, stones on the rails, or both. JR West said it found grinding marks on the rails that are often made when a train runs over such objects as stones, but added they had not confirmed any causal relationship between the marks and the accident. Officials of a transport ministry accident investigation committee, however, said they could not find signs that the train ran over stones nor that a brake had been applied. The Hyogo police opened a criminal investigation Tuesday into JR West on suspicion of professional negligence resulting in death and injury. The death toll from the derailment rose to at least 75. Hyogo Prefectural Police investigators confiscated materials from the offices of JR West that may be related to the crash, which also injured 456 people -- 150 of them seriously. A rescue team found a uniformed man believed to be the driver, Ryujiro Takami, 23, in the driver's seat. He did not respond to calls from the rescuers, who weren't able to reach the body. Earlier Tuesday, three people trapped inside the mangled lead car of the train were pulled out of the wreckage alive after an overnight rescue operation. They were identified as Ryosuke Yamashita, 18, Hiroki Hayashi, 19, and Yuko Oshita, 46. The rescuers used equipment to detect heartbeats with electromagnetic waves and carefully removed wreckage piece by piece. However, hopes of finding more survivors faded as the rescue operation entered into its second evening. Police said they believe there were at least 14 people -- apparently dead -- still trapped inside the wreckage of the two mangled cars. The accident occurred at 9:18 a.m. on JR West's Fukuchiyama Line, when five cars of a seven-car train carrying some 580 people derailed on a curve in Amagasaki, just west of Osaka. The first two cars plowed into the first-floor parking garage of a nine-story apartment building. Takami, who had been on the job for 11 months, overshot a station stop in June last year by 100 meters , JR West said. The train was heading from Takarazuka Station in Hyogo Prefecture to Doshishamae Station in Kyoto Prefecture. automatic transfer switch used in the area is the oldest model available and does not have the capability to trigger automatic braking when trains go by too quickly, the Land, Infrastructure and Transport Ministry said. On Monday, JR West initially announced that at Itami Station, the train's last stop before crashing, the driver overran the stop mark by about 8 meters and had to back up before the passengers could be let off. But the company corrected that figure Tuesday and said he overshot the mark by 40 meters . The train's conductor, Masatoshi Matsushita, 42, told JR West officials that the driver asked him after the incident at Itami Station to under-report the overrun distance, so he radioed the command center three minutes later and said the train had overrun the stop point by 8 meters , according to JR West. The train then left the station about 90 seconds behind schedule and passed Tsukaguchi Station about one minute late. Many of the injured said the train seemed to be traveling faster than usual after leaving Itami Station, as if the driver was hurrying to make up for the delay. Just before the accident, JR West's command center contacted the driver twice but he did not respond, according to the railway company.
YOKOHAMA POST 27_04_2005 Wednesday 27.04.2005, CET 08:39 Japan police raid train operator after crash By Issei Kato
Reuters
|
||||